Workers compensation insurance is something every business owner needs to understand. It protects employees who get hurt at work and protects employers from big lawsuits. This guide will explain everything in simple words that anyone can understand.
Table of Contents
What is Workers Compensation Insurance?
Workers compensation insurance is like a safety net for workers. If someone gets hurt while doing their job, this insurance helps pay for:
For the Injured Worker
✓ Doctor visits and hospital bills ✓ Money to replace lost wages ✓ Physical therapy and rehabilitation ✓ Disability payments if they cannot work
For the Business Owner
✓ Protection from expensive lawsuits ✓ Legal fees if there are problems ✓ Compliance with state laws ✓ Peace of mind knowing employees are covered
Think of it like car insurance – you hope you never need it, but you must have it just in case something bad happens.
Why Do Businesses Need This Insurance?
It is Required by Law
Almost every state in America requires businesses to have workers compensation insurance. If you have employees and don’t have this insurance, you can:
- Get fined thousands of dollars
- Face criminal charges
- Be personally responsible for all medical bills
- Have your business shut down
It Protects Everyone
Without this insurance:
- Workers might sue you if they get hurt
- You could lose your house and business
- Medical bills could cost hundreds of thousands of dollars
- Your business reputation could be ruined
Top Workers Compensation Insurance Companies in 2025
#1 The Hartford
The Hartford offers the best and cheapest workers’ comp insurance in California, starting at $48 per month and is one of the oldest and most reliable insurance providers.
Why The Hartford is Great: 🏆 Very experienced with workers comp 🏆 Good prices starting at $48/month 🏆 Strong network of doctors 🏆 Easy claims process 🏆 Good customer service
Best For: Small businesses looking for reliable, affordable coverage
#2 Travelers Insurance
Connecticut-based Travelers top the list in this line of business and is among American Financial Group, Travelers and Old Republic Group that top the list.
Travelers Advantages: ★ Biggest workers comp insurance company ★ Available in all states ★ Good at preventing workplace injuries ★ Fast claim payments ★ Strong financial rating
Best For: Businesses that want the most experienced company
#3 Hiscox
We chose Hiscox as our pick for the overall best workers’ comp insurance according to multiple 2025 rankings.
Why Hiscox is Popular: • Great for small businesses • Easy online application • Good customer service • Competitive prices • Simple to understand policies
Best For: Small businesses and professional services
#4 Liberty Mutual
Liberty Mutual is rated as having the best workers’ compensation insurance customer service.
Liberty Mutual Benefits: → Best customer service → Large company with good resources → Available everywhere → Good safety programs → Fair claim handling
Best For: Businesses that want excellent customer service
#5 Progressive
Progressive is rated as best workers’ compensation insurance for professional offices.
Progressive Strengths: 💡 Great for office workers 💡 Good online tools 💡 Competitive prices 💡 Easy to manage policies 💡 Good for low-risk businesses
Best For: Professional offices and low-risk businesses
Other Top Companies to Consider
NEXT Insurance
Its rating from the Better Business Bureau remains at a B with a 4.07 out of 5 stars and has a 4.7 out of 5 stars on Trust Pilot.
NEXT Insurance Features: • Fully digital company • Very easy to buy online • Good ratings from customers • Fast processing • Good for small businesses
Chubb Insurance
Chubb’s workers’ comp policy fits a wide range of businesses.
Chubb Advantages: • Good for many types of businesses • Strong financial rating • Excellent claim service • Premium coverage options • Good for larger businesses
Old Republic Group
Old Republic Group is among the top companies listed for 2025.
Old Republic Positives: • Very stable company • Good prices • Available in many states • Focus on workers compensation • Good claim handling
How Workers Compensation Works
When Someone Gets Hurt at Work
- Report Immediately: Tell your insurance company right away
- Get Medical Care: Worker goes to approved doctor
- Fill Out Forms: Complete accident report forms
- Investigation: Insurance company checks what happened
- Benefits Start: If approved, worker gets money and medical care
Types of Injuries Covered
• Cuts and bruises from accidents • Back injuries from lifting heavy things • Burns from hot equipment • Falls from ladders or stairs • Repetitive stress injuries (like carpal tunnel) • Occupational diseases (like lung problems from chemicals)
What is NOT Covered
❌ Injuries that happen outside of work ❌ Injuries from fighting or horseplay ❌ Injuries when worker was drunk or on drugs ❌ Self-inflicted injuries ❌ Injuries from personal activities during breaks
How Much Does Workers Compensation Cost?
Factors That Affect Price
Type of Work
- Office workers: $0.50 – $2.00 per $100 of payroll
- Construction workers: $5.00 – $15.00 per $100 of payroll
- Manufacturing workers: $2.00 – $8.00 per $100 of payroll
Other Cost Factors: • Number of employees • Company’s safety record • State where business is located • Amount of payroll • Previous claims history
Example Costs
Small Office (5 employees, $200,000 payroll):
- Monthly cost: $80 – $300
Small Construction Company (10 employees, $500,000 payroll):
- Monthly cost: $2,000 – $6,000
Small Restaurant (8 employees, $240,000 payroll):
- Monthly cost: $200 – $800
Ways to Save Money on Workers Compensation
Keep Workplace Safe
🛡️ Train employees on safety rules 🛡️ Provide safety equipment 🛡️ Fix dangerous conditions quickly 🛡️ Have regular safety meetings 🛡️ Reward safe behavior
Choose Right Classification
- Make sure your business is classified correctly
- Wrong classification can cost you thousands extra
- Work with agent to verify job codes
- Update classifications when business changes
Shop Around Every Year
- Compare quotes from multiple companies
- Prices can vary by thousands of dollars
- Some companies specialize in your industry
- Don’t automatically renew with same company
Maintain Good Records
- Keep accurate payroll records
- Document all safety training
- Report claims immediately
- Maintain clean workplace
Consider Higher Deductibles
- Higher deductible = lower premium
- Make sure you can afford the deductible
- Good for businesses with few claims
- Can save 10-20% on premium
Different Ways to Buy Workers Compensation
Traditional Insurance Companies
How it works: You pay premiums to insurance company, they handle all claims
Good for: ✓ Small businesses ✓ New businesses ✓ Businesses with few employees ✓ High-risk industries
State Insurance Funds
How it works: Some states run their own workers comp insurance
Available in these states: • California (State Compensation Insurance Fund) • New York (New York State Insurance Fund) • Ohio (Bureau of Workers’ Compensation) • Washington (Department of Labor & Industries)
Self-Insurance
How it works: Large companies pay claims directly instead of buying insurance
Requirements: • Usually need 500+ employees • Must prove financial ability to pay claims • Need approval from state • Must post large bonds
Group Self-Insurance
How it works: Multiple small companies join together to share costs
Good for: • Similar types of businesses • Companies in same industry • Businesses wanting more control • Companies with good safety records
Red Flags – Companies to Avoid
Warning Signs of Bad Companies
🚩 Premiums much lower than others (too good to be true) 🚩 Not licensed in your state 🚩 Poor customer service ratings 🚩 Many complaints about claim denials 🚩 Weak financial ratings 🚩 No local presence or support
How to Check Company Quality
• Look up AM Best financial ratings • Check state insurance department websites • Read customer reviews online • Ask other business owners about their experiences • Verify company is licensed in your state
Important Things to Remember
For Business Owners
• You MUST have this insurance if you have employees • Coverage starts from the first day of employment • Independent contractors may need coverage too • Penalties for not having insurance are severe • This insurance protects YOUR business and assets
For Employees
• You are covered from your first day at work • Report injuries immediately to your boss • Get medical care from approved doctors • You may get money to replace lost wages • You cannot sue your employer for covered injuries
Questions to Ask Before Buying
About Coverage
• What injuries and illnesses are covered? • Which doctors can treat injured workers? • How much will workers get paid if they can’t work? • What happens if someone dies at work?
About Claims
• How do I report an injury? • How long does it take to process claims? • Will you help manage the claims process? • What if a worker wants to return to work?
About Costs
• How do you calculate my premium? • What discounts are available? • Can my rates go up during the year? • What happens if my payroll changes?
About Service
• Do you offer safety training programs? • How can I contact you in an emergency? • Do you have local representatives? • What online tools do you provide?
Special Situations
Independent Contractors
• May need their own workers comp insurance • Some states require you to cover them • Get certificates of insurance from contractors • Verify their coverage is current
Part-Time Workers
• Usually covered under your policy • Include their wages in payroll calculations • Same benefits as full-time workers • Report all part-time workers to insurance company
Seasonal Workers
• Covered during work season • Adjust payroll estimates for seasonal changes • May affect your premium calculations • Keep good records of seasonal employment
Remote Workers
• Usually still covered under your policy • Home office injuries may be covered • Travel to company events typically covered • Check with insurance company about specific situations
Summary: Best Choices for Different Business Types
Small Offices and Professional Services
- Progressive – Best for professional offices
- Hiscox – Great overall choice for small businesses
- The Hartford – Reliable and affordable
Construction and High-Risk Work
- Travelers – Most experience with construction
- Liberty Mutual – Good safety programs
- The Hartford – Strong claims handling
Restaurants and Retail
- The Hartford – Good prices and service
- Liberty Mutual – Excellent customer service
- Travelers – Large network and resources
Very Small Businesses (1-5 employees)
- NEXT Insurance – Easy online buying
- Hiscox – Simple policies
- Progressive – Good for low-risk businesses
Larger Businesses (50+ employees)
- Travelers – Best resources and experience
- Liberty Mutual – Comprehensive services
- Chubb – Premium coverage options
Remember: The cheapest insurance is not always the best insurance. Look for a company that will help you prevent injuries, handle claims fairly, and provide good service when you need it most.
For more information about workers compensation requirements in your state, visit the U.S. Department of Labor website or check with your state’s workers compensation board. You can also find consumer protection information at the National Association of Insurance Commissioners.
Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and should not be considered as professional insurance or legal advice. Workers compensation insurance requirements, rates, and coverage vary significantly by state and type of business. Some information may not apply to all states or situations. Please consult with licensed insurance professionals and your state’s workers compensation board for specific requirements and current rates. Laws and regulations change frequently, so verify all information with appropriate authorities before making business decisions. The author and publisher are not responsible for any decisions made based on the information provided in this article.